Malaysian policy making needs to be rooted in reality

KUALA LUMPUR -- Malaysian policy making tends to suppress the difference in realities of income levels among households across the country with a contextless approach and by copying international standards considered “best practices” of high income positions.

Khazanah Research Institute (KRI) Director Dr Suraya Ismail said if policy makers do not root the policy based on the context of the different realities people were experiencing, then the target would definitely be missed.

“For example, for the price of affordable housing, if just one number is cited, it would not be right for different states with different income levels. If we put RM180,000 as the affordable price in Selangor, it cannot be the case for those in Kelantan.

“This somehow does not resonate in policy making in thinking everybody is facing the same reality,” she told a dialogue session in conjunction with the launch of the State of Households 2018: Different Realities Report.

In its latest report, KRI said since independence, Malaysia had advanced on a clear path of progress. However, it said, economic realities across Malaysian households are much more disparate, with difficult challenges remaining, such as persistent low incomes, an increasing gap between the rich and poor, geographic inequality and undervalued care work.

The report also stated that there was significant geographical diversity in household income across Malaysia.

“Nationally, the middle 40 per cent (M40) household refers to those with a monthly income of between RM4,360 and RM9,619. However, if we consider the income distribution at state level, the equivalent state-level thresholds vary significantly.

“A top 20 per cent (T20) household in Kelantan, Perlis or Pahang may have an equivalent of a bottom 40 per cent (B40) household in Kuala Lumpur.

“These are the things that really need to be ironed out, to come up with proper targeted policies that need to understand the realities faced at state level and even at the federal level, no policies fit all,” Suraya said.

She also said the thinking is that international benchmarks were great, Bernama report.

“But, to address any problem of a specific target group, we need to cut the coat according to the cloth,” she added.

She suggested that in policy making, the target set must be accompanied with a proposed solution which is actionable by respective agencies, arguing on the saying of a “wonderful policy but bad execution”.

“No policy is good if it does not take into account the limits of institutional strength,’ Suraya said.

Comments

Kementerian Pendidikan nafi tak sambung kontrak syarikat kawalan keselamatan

KUALA LUMPUR -- Kementerian Pendidikan (KPM) menafikan dakwaan Persatuan Industri Keselamatan Malaysia (PIKM) bahawa kementerian tidak menyambung kontrak syarikat perkhidmatan kawalan keselamatan yang tamat tempoh pada 31 Dis lepas. Dalam satu kenyataan, KPM menegaskan kesemua kontrak yang tamat tempoh itu telah ditender semula mengikut keperluan semasa, norma baharu kementerian. "KPM tidak pernah menganiaya mana-mana pihak dalam perkara ini dan tidak pernah menamatkan perkhidmatan 12,000 pengawal keselamatan seperti yang didakwa PIKM. "Kontrak yang ditender semula disertai oleh syarikat kawalan keselamatan yang berdaftar dengan Kementerian Dalam Negeri dan Kementerian Kewangan berdasarkan keperluan semasa seperti bilangan syif dan pekerja," kata kenyataan itu. KPM berkata syarikat yang pernah mendapat kontrak daripada kementerian sebelum ini juga menyertai proses tender yang dijalankan secara adil, telus dan penuh berintegriti. Presiden PIKM Datuk Seri Mu

Proton SUV open for booking at RM1,000

KUALA LUMPUR -- National car maker, Proton Holdings Bhd, is adopting an alphanumerical naming system for its future models beginning with the X70, its first sport utility vehicle (SUV). Sales and Marketing Vice-President Abdul Rashid Musa said the letter X is synonymous with crossover or SUV vehicles, while the number 70 denoted the size or class of the SUV and would enable Proton to adopt a logical system to add bigger or smaller models in the future. “This is the first time an alphanumerical naming system is used on a Proton model as our research shows it will make it easier to sell in ASEAN and other international markets, as there are no language barriers to overcome,” he told reporters at the preview of the new SUV. Proton Chief Executive Officer Dr Li Chunrong said Proton's adoption of the new naming system would make customer more focus on the brand name as compared with the model name. Abdul Rashid, who is also the Chief Executive Officer of Proton E

Mahkamah meriah dengan tahanan reman lindungi rumah urut

PUTRAJAYA -- Mahkamah Majistret di sini “meriah” susulan prosiding reman beramai-ramai melibatkan 14 individu termasuk tujuh penjawat awam berkaitan dakwaan memberi dan menerima wang sogokan bagi melindungi premis urut di Kuala Lumpur. Tujuh penjawat awam terbabit ialah tiga anggota polis termasuk seorang ketua balai, seorang pegawai bomba dan tiga petugas Dewan Bandaraya Kuala Lumpur. Mereka berserta tiga lagi orang awam yang disyaki berperanan sebagai ‘runner’ atau utusan dibawa ke mahkamah itu pada kira-kira 10 pagi menaiki bas Suruhanjaya Pencegahan Rasuah Malaysia (SPRM), menyusuli empat lagi individu dipercayai pemilik premis yang tiba di mahkamah itu kira-kira sejam sebelumnya, menaiki van SPRM. Prosiding reman terhadap kesemua mereka tamat pada kira-kira pukul 1.30 tengah hari dengan Majistret Ahmad Asyraf Mohammad Kamal membenarkan permohonan SPRM untuk menahan reman 10 daripada mereka termasuk tujuh penjawat awam terbabit sehingga Jumaat ini. Empat pem

Paper Buruk

Search This Blog